Shared note

Food Law as Field and Community

rec_1794583771785_joined.m4a

Intentionally in conversation to make sure that we have that to send and maintain those, because I do think there's a bit of, like, inertia towards maybe consensus or concurrence like that. And maybe to go to answer Heather's challenge, dissent is valid, or part of the value. But maybe that is the thing that we actually all agree on, is just that we dissent, even if we disagree, that we kind of commit to that as being a sort of central feature. I don't know if that's like a hedge or a dodge, but that does seem important to me, actually. And the people that I talk to in all of this and we're kind of reflecting on it, they seem to think that that's important and a particular value. It's something that is sort of diverse, that our experiences and their opinions. So that's all. Those are maybe thoughts, I guess, on this, but I'll pass over. Great, thanks. So maybe before I go on to my prepared remarks, I don't want to stack, I think, the discussion of diversity of views and dissent is kind of helpful in terms of thinking about just, like, I would ask the audience, I don't think anyone assumes that in the property law everyone has the same foundational values, or contract law, or I don't know, opinions, but we don't question the discipline. So I think it would be—we're kind of asking questions like, I think also in international law that's referring to the existence of things, international law thing, and what it is. But if I kind of rewind, I think the way that I came to food law comes from, I think Katrina was mentioning it earlier, that when I was in law school, no one knew what to do with me. I wanted to do, like, stable food systems, and they would send me to, oh, so-and-so does, like, environmental pollution related to ships, like maybe you should talk to— or like this person, and I remember talking to these national law people and saying, you know, there's international right to food, and they were like, oh, really? Interesting topic. So, like, there wasn't really a space. And so I actually found my first kind of academic space in the Canadian Association for Food Studies, CAFS, where what was interesting to me was that there are a lot of people who were not in law who were constantly talking about laws and regulations. And so you had, you know, and for me, I was working on meat systems, and you had geographers who were writing about the impact of, you know, new food safety regulation on, you know, meat processors in the province, or you have people working on, you know, temporary migrant workers and, you know, closed work permits, and— The original group was because we'd kind of come out of the law schools and no one was talking about those questions. And so to me, the idea of, you know, the first food law conference 10 years ago was, okay, finally there are people who are kind of asking these questions and looking at them from a legal perspective, and there's this community where we have this shared language. So when you're talking to anthropologists, talking to geographers, you can be working on the same topic, but you don't necessarily have the same understanding. And it's just like things, you cite things differently, and I don't use footnotes, you might not read things without footnotes. It's just like it's a different worldview. And so there was a lot of comfort in being able to speak to other lawyers. And I think that the idea of the association, when we created it, was to create a space, right, that community where people who were coming from a legal background and were suddenly kind of realizing that we were converging on topics that had some overlap, and we weren't necessarily all experts in the legal framework, but we could kind of help each other out to understand where we were coming from in terms of the way in which we conducted our research or the way that people conducted their practice. But over time, I guess like one of the things that I felt with thinking about this as a field, or is it a lens through which we look at things, or is it a community, is that I think that one of the things that's maybe important for a field that we might see in property law is the idea of depth, that even when you are critiquing things and having different points of view, that there's also kind of a shared framework that you're either rejecting or kind of working with or responding to, and one of the things that can be tricky. And good law, and I think it might be different across generations. Like, I think, you know, Don, like, you go to 10 years ago or 100 years ago, it's also geography. I think that the question of food law as a field is different in Canada than it is in the U.S., than it is in Europe. Like, one of the things, and I think this is where sometimes I feel the limits of it being a field in terms of an academic field as opposed to a community of scholars, is if we bring everyone in here together, the chances of having more than three people who are actually working on the same piece of legislation or the same—

Discipline where there's constitutional law and labor is quite small, and so the ability to go deep in that community is, I think, more limited in Canada just because we're a smaller country. I think that if you're in the U.S. or if you're in Europe, I mean, you just have more universities, more scholars working on these things, and so if you have, you know, two whatever—one in every university—you just have more people than we do in Canada. And we also don't have things like, I mean, the farm bill in the U.S., like there are a lot of people will all be kind of following and they'll be responding to it. Or in Europe, the Common Agricultural Policy. When I go to the European food law conferences, it's always, I kind of go, Oh wow, so amazing, we're all talking about the same thing. Like, you are all following the same thing and have different thoughts on it. And I get a little bit envious because there's that ability to kind of work and learn, and this person's looking at it from this perspective, this person from this perspective, and you kind of build on it. And so, I don't know, I think maybe kind of before—I'm thinking out loud and I was thinking this before—I think that, like, I've been maybe saying to Natty, I wish I had these conversations, like, Oh, I don't know, it's not our field. But maybe it's a generation thing and that we're just not there yet. Maybe in 10 years, but I mean, I think that maybe that the law school was, well, what about the two universities in Ontario that are going to get, like, new law school, more law schools and more academics to have more perspectives so that we can be more than one person working on each topic. So I think, like, we have this community to look at food systems, like look at food law through the lens of food systems, and that's been really helpful. And I think also just good for morale. But then when you want to go a bit deeper. There's going to be a limit to how much you can push that. Maybe I'll stop there. So I always feel anxiety about saying I teach people, and maybe even coming from the U.S., I'm like, I'm the only one. I don't have any greats or bads. That problem still feels very descriptive of my life. I went back to my syllabus last night to just see how I structured it, because I realized my syllabus is a little defensive. So in my learning outcomes, I tell my students, I'm like, you're going to learn the history of food law, that you're going to learn in the class is not one of our learning outcomes, right? And then I have this list of things, like you're going to learn WTO agricultural trade rules, you're going to learn about food aid, you're going to learn about the right to food, and you're going to learn about food sovereignty movements, and you're going to learn a little bit about biotechnology regulation of seeds, and you're going to learn about local, Philly municipal rules about land and gardens, which is just a hodgepodge of doctrine and rules and little bits of legislation. It's kind of a list. It certainly doesn't feel like a field. And then I tried to tell my students, but wait, I promise you it's coherent. I've thought about this. And so I'd say the course is built around one big idea, which I don't—I mean, I'm going to say this big idea, and then I'd actually caveat it, but I don't for the students, but the market as a legal concept. And so how we think about law and capitalism is also, you know, it's how we think about shifts in how food is produced and consumed and distributed are ways of tracking shifts in how we think about law and capitalism. So that's my organizing question for a class. It's not really an organizing question for a field, but it's something that I keep saying to my students as they're doing all of these bits of diverse law that might not hang together. We're asking how law builds food markets. We're asking who these markets serve. We're asking how people can use law to rebuild them. And I've just, you know, I've thought maybe to be concrete, I'd say a tiny bit about the course and then back to food a little bit, right? So I'm having the students read food regime literature, the amazing Harriet Friedmann in Toronto and Philip McMichael, and I'm having them read that literature alongside stuff like Wendy Kennedy's reglobalizations of legal thought so that they can think about, say, the Green Revolution in food aid as an instance of state-managed intervention in agriculture, or they can think about structural adjustment and the creation of the WTO as, you know, a revival of neoliberal ideas. Or they can move to the contemporary moment and think about experiments in commonsing or community land trusts or producer and consumer cooperatives.

And then I can ask them, okay, so, like, what hodgepodge of legal theories are you working with? And, you know, are we configuring new ones? And I don't know, I always feel very like, oh, am I going to do food law with this class? But food is so useful for a class like this because it's a boundary object, right? It means different things for different groups, and that's really useful to me, in particular because it straddles public and private. It's a commodity. It's a right. But it's not, you know, it's not the only boundary object, right? It's land, water, energy. Lots of things sort of straddle public-private, commons goods, price-mediated exchange, in ways that can really open up bigger questions of legal theory. So then I was like, well, maybe now I'm just obsessed with boundary objects as a field. But then as I was listening to you all, I was like, it's actually such a great boundary object in another way. It's flexible enough that there's enough interpretive flexibility, and at the same time solid and general enough to create community, right? So Jamie used the language family resemblance. Sarah talked about shared language. Kind of Heather talked about foundational values, but values that are weak enough maybe, or with Jamie's sort of weak enough to build in dissent so that we can still have content but coordinate. You know, there's a way in which it is acting for us like a kind of informational and material anchor that lets this kind of channeling some of Sarah's comments, legal scholars with all these different expertise coordinate. Like we actually can get together and think about how to solve a shared problem, or how to build a conference and a shared conversation. And to me, for Jamie's final question about external coherence, I feel like doing this work is probably enough, right, and that the external coherence will come. And I say all this even though whenever anyone says, like— Do you do food a lot? I'm like, ugh. But maybe I should just say yes. Yeah, yeah. Great. My baby's sleeping, she's asleep, so I'll try and say something. We'll see how it goes. Jamie, you gave a copy out of your organizing conference brain. I also have co-parenting with your brain, so let's see if I can be coherent. So I don't really know what makes a field. Jamie and I started writing a paper on this question of what's a field almost a decade ago, and we did some research and then sort of abandoned it. But my kind of weak memory is similar to what Heather said, which is that scholars have generally said you have a field when law shapes particular areas or behaviors or patterns in consistent ways, or when a kind of legal field responds to particular reoccurring problems over and over again, and law there is sort of a central to shaping outward things in the world. What struck me over the years in this work that we've been doing is instead the particular kind of values that have been inscribed into law, and what appears, at least in my, like, this very preliminary early thinking in this topic, is a kind of set of particular values that I see appearing over and over again, either in how the law is being shaped from the outside or how the law is responding to the challenges that it has created. And this kind of overarching value, I guess I'm doing something a bit different than my co-panelists in suggesting maybe there is a kind of coherency, but to me this coherency that I see over and over again is the way in which this policy idea or commitment to cheap food. has shaped many areas like government food law, and then has kind of reconstituted food systems in response to this kind of reoccurring practice of cheapness that happens over and over again. So maybe I would propose that there is some underlying logic to these kind of disparate areas, and that underlying logic is a commitment to cheapness and then a responding to the effects of cheapness. So how have I kind of

Come to think about it, those are notice. I guess maybe reways in scholarship and conference and in teaching. So maybe I'll say something a bit about each. So at the conferences, one of the things that struck me is the way in which these disparate areas that Jamie mentioned sometimes feel hard to kind of all bring together have often been organized around this question of cheapness. So devaluing animals, not having more animal safety because we want meat proteins to be cheaper, and doing all of these things that would make it more expensive to grow animals is not what the law wants to do. And then the law needs to respond to the ways in which food has been made cheap by doing different kinds of food safety regulations, maybe always having bigger enterprises that are easy to regulate. And so cheapness is kind of wound up in the whole thing. Same goes for labor, always kind of pushing down on questions of labor and food systems, pitting farmers against workers in ways because we always want the outcome of food to be cheap, and that has to fall on somebody. So we have agricultural exception rules that make it so we don't have labor employment laws that apply the same way in agriculture that they do in other areas. I think we could tell a similar story kind of for food safety. I think Sarah does in her work about the kind of constant scaling up that happens in response to fears that are kind of born about questions of the need to make food cheap. And in order to make food cheap, we need to have these bigger enterprises that can regulate the kind of safety concerns that would be much harder to regulate and much more expensive on smaller scales. We could talk about food fraud. There's a whole variety of areas. Food security, the fact that we are constantly responding to food security not by questions of public responsibility or the right to food, but by trying to make prices cheaper. In my scholarship too, I've also come up against this question of food over and over again, in the ways in which international legal rules have marginalized rural places and people, seen them always as sites of extraction. And so the kind of lowest value is always the food producers. They're always the ones exploited, always extracted from. I wish I could have taken Amy's food law policy class. I think I would have learned so much doing that. But I teach food law in a kind of different way, but maybe connected in some, although I really appreciate your language and thinking about it as markets. But I've tried to, in thinking, in planning my food law courses and teaching them, trying to think about what it is that I'm doing, particularly because I probably have two students who care about food law in my class, and then the rest are just taking it because they want an elective that sounds fun. So how do I appeal to those people? And the kind of result that I come to as the kind of organizing principle of my food law course is one about how values are translated into law and how law deals with competing values. So the other kind of big classes I teach are labor and property law, and particularly in property law, it's sort of always hard to see what the policy choices are or how values are being entered into the law, though they always are in every decision. But it's much more opaque and kind of hard to pull out the consequences of those value thinking for people, for animals, for places, for land, for territories, etc. But in food law, it's so easy to see the fights over values. They're always very apparent. Do we do this thing that protects the environment more, or do we do this thing that allows us to export more? There's always these, like, tensions that are so visible, and the fights over what rules we have are so visible, as the consequences of how we set those rules are also easier to identify than they are in an area like property law. And I've just repeatedly been struck when I teach. See the agricultural labor and food processing and labor lean and packaging and international food trade and all of these various topics that, as Amy and Damian, Heather, et cetera, have all been a little bit disparate.

Is this kind of deep-seated connection to this question of cheapness and always the need for food to be cheap. Now, I think it would be very easy to say, and I haven't thought this through very much, that all of this is, of course, now is just capitalism, and it would be an easy critique to say in my response, it's just capitalism all the way down, taken in various particular forms at different times, and that's probably right. Maybe there's nothing particularly special about food here. But I do think food has been historically treated differently than other sorts of kind of commodities like housing. We do think about housing, we do think that there might be some sort of state responsibility there. We do have kind of laws that protect how much you can increase rents. There is a sense in which that other commodity we do treat quite differently than food, where we don't have, at least in Canada, the same sorts of restrictions. And when I look at the kind of resistance that exists in the world to the ways in which laws have governed food systems and the kinds of alternative responses that people out there in the world want to cost accounting and measuring ecological footprints, rebuilding laws around food sovereignty or agroecology or peasants' rights or workers' rights, they're often about tackling this question of really valuing food for what it is, or rethinking about it as not just a commodity that needs always to be cheaper, but something connected to the ways in which we build community, we think about connection to our past. Michael Fakhri has this line where he says, The right to food is about how we show love. If that's true, if that's the kind of resistance, then maybe that also points to this kind of— overlying logic that might connect a lot of what our disparate fields are. So, yeah, maybe just quickly, what's at stake then in how we answer this? I wonder if another kind of level or activity that colleagues in some days food law gives us, beyond building community, as we said, or we've all said, or kind of managing resistance, is also about providing us tools for asking similar questions. So it's true, I'm not going to find anybody else who's looking at the UN Committee on World Food Security's agroecology policy, and Sarah, you might not find anybody who's looking at this particular food safety regulation. But maybe how you look at that food safety regulation and how I look at this committee on World Food Security policy involves us asking pretty similar questions about who benefits, what the costs are, what the impact are on certain people, the ways in which it co-creates a kind of food system in particular ways and not others. And so maybe it gives us, even if we're not talking about always the same subject matter, a set of questions that are common amongst us. And again, they're probably common in other fields as well, but they give us a kind of sense of community within worlds where we often feel maybe isolated in what we're doing and studying. Yeah, so there's my thoughts. It took a bit of a different turn than others, but. Before we exit the conversation. I think we've also answered the second question to a degree, so maybe we can do some kind of back-and-forth response, and if you feel like you have an answer to the states question, maybe just bring that in to your next comments. And then I don't feel like I can actually moderate, I'm sorry, I can't facilitate people that well because I'm just talking to you, but— Nadi, why don't we do like one more quick round, and then we'll open it up to others in the room who've got another half hour. Folks have like one good thing they want to say in response. Okay. Okay, so to be quick— or long. I get that. Well, I was thinking from a very practical perspective, why does it matter whether we have something that people externally recognize or we've got systems? So just very basically, as a researcher, when you go to apply for grants or funding, you have to squeeze yourself into a health law grant or an environmental grant or some other kind of grant that isn't— it's not recognized.

As a holistic democratic soul. And then if you're trying to build sort of research partnerships in multidisciplinary areas, like you said, there's so many food experts in every discipline, and I think they rarely think of lawyers because they don't think that there's such a thing as lawyers, and what they think about us, they're very excited and often want to collaborate. So that's a very, very practical thing. And in terms of teaching, you know, just in terms of being able to persuade the advice that you can be allowed to have this course, that students will come, whatever, you can show your success. And like I think I mentioned before, just having sort of credibility that you're going to talk to policymakers and people, that you're a food law expert. You're not just an environmental law expert talking to farmers, or you're not just a, you know, a social justice person talking, you know, etc. So I think that that can be a helpful, those very practical points. But more broadly, I think some of the things, I think this moves us on to maybe what might be the third question, what Jamie was saying is, what should we do next? So, you know, do we need to grow? Are we enough? Are we doing, should we be very satisfied with what we've already done? If not, you know, how can we grow awareness of the food system and the role of the law within it? How can we grow capacity to address these issues and, you know, ... growing the next generation of leaders to respond to this type of thing? How can we expand tools that are available to tackle the injustices and problems within the food system? What would be one of the most recent things I'm working on is the national school food policy, because there's just no way that you can tackle that without a multidisciplinary... Okay, so I didn't get section two, like kind of connected to on the why it matters. But as people were talking the first time, I wrote down to myself, food is good to pick with. And then I realized I think what I need. So, I guess. Okay, so give my idea. Okay. So on the why it matters, again, just having two anecdotes from, like, what is on my mind lately. So one relates to research. It relates to what Heather was saying a little bit about, you know, kind of funding. So I had this vice dean position of research at law school, and so I spent a lot of time thinking about the strategic kind of things around research. And we are seeing so much on dual fronts around, one, government-led priorities, right? The government, the feds, particularly giving us lists of things, you know, something matters, but then we need to speak to if we want to be competitive for funding, and they want to talk in language of impact. And so, and I'm thinking a little bit about, like, I guess Don's comments from this morning too about kind of getting ready for the thing, and you're not quite sure, you know, what it's going to be, but trying to build some resilience. And I think that's part of the why it matters question, is that, like, at least when they said that we care about that it matters, you know, for your research or for the things you want to do with your research or the partners that you have maybe elsewhere, that there is something like a strategic question here about how we, you know, think about this like a field presented. And then maybe also, it's not so much about just coming up with one line, it's think about how it actually fits into those kind of strategic priorities that increasingly I think we're being given. We don't actually get to define them. I think, I mean, this is where our flexibility is a strength to the degree. You know, like defense is a big one these days, and food security repackaged in the language of defense, I think, is something that maybe a bunch of us are seeing coming down the pipe and thinking about. Like, how do we respond to that? Is that something that we just try to entirely resist, or is there ways to kind of, like, make an influence, I guess, how that conversation is playing out? So that's one. And then two, on the teaching and practice side, I guess the answer I have is I've been working a lot on sort of agricultural land trusts, and in particular the National Farmers Foundation these days, in trying to steward farmland and open accessibility. And so we're, like, taking land ownership, building allies to do that, and engaging increasingly with lawyers in practice who we need to break the expertise. And we're having a lot of trouble finding lawyers who are well positioned to understand food systems and agricultural systems. Like, we can find a charities lawyer, we can find a real estate lawyer, we can find a contracts lawyer who knows their field such as it were, but they don't have the kind of deep understanding of the need in trying to kind of build this sort of national program around farmland.

Juristic access. And so I didn't see it there from a really practical perspective. So kind of why it matters, which is if we have lawyers who are trained from that conflict systems knowledge, then that would be a huge benefit on the client side for those kinds of particular projects. So I do think that that matters. Great. So then maybe in reverse order, just to be like a lawyer, I'll probably get into later, but, like, again, one of the reasons why I'm questioning the field after spending so long justifying its existence, my entire PhD was about saying that the field is food law, and resisting, like, my supervisor who said, So it's administrative law. No, it's food law. It's food law. And now the question is, I'm just thinking, like, anecdotally, some of our founding board members who started off in private practice who were food law practitioners left the board over time because they were transitioning to other areas of corporate law and kind of had an interest, but then, you know, their practice moved in different directions. And so it does feel like, when there's academics, law practitioners, like there are moments in time when you enter it and you see these connections, but also your practice can evolve and suddenly, you know, you're no longer really dealing with those files. And so I think in different areas, which point out the public's claim, like there's so few who are available to really respond to those calls. I was thinking about Maggie's point about the idea of a policy commitment to cheap food, and I think that that connects to the idea of, like, law and political economy. So people who are thinking about law and political economy, maybe in the field, like thinking about food as an illustration of that definitely makes sense. But then if we're thinking about food law policy as a field, you know, I would want to make sure that we're also thinking about, you know, the long history of this geographic indigations, and, like, I don't think that the after-dinner champagne is a policy commitment to cheap food. That's a different conversation than a different— so I think that there are different spaces and, you know, the history of agricultural law in Canada, whether it was being taught in Eastern law schools, I mean, out west, though— Succession planning on the farm. Again, so I think that food law, that's also the challenge. We can't even, I think, align over this one idea of food, given that we're definitely seeing a lot of that in society. But if you are kind of true to the definition, the expansive definition you've given, then, you know, there are other spaces where it's not only about food, and so how do we have that space for all of those if you want it to be a field? Like one of the things that I've found is over time, I often get media requests to comment about things as a food lawyer, and like nine times out of ten, I can't. And sometimes I'll have to, What do you think about, you know, increasing grocery prices? It's like, yeah, that's definitely connected to the political economy of food, but I don't have the data to comment on this. Or, you know, what do you think about, I don't know, someone actually talking about wild animals and conventions, I do farmed animals, but I don't know how the Minister of Agriculture, you know, phone deals with deer. And so that's kind of the space where you sometimes feel, why does it matter? Like I sometimes get a bit, I feel a bit awkward, like if I can't comment on this, does it mean something? I don't know. The constitutional experts get called on, you know, and they can kind of always respond. But when someone's like, Oh, this is related to food, and you're a food lawyer, and most of the time I have to say, That's not me, it makes me feel a bit insecure about the field, even though, like, collectively, you know, and then that's also why it's nice to have this community, so I can always forward the request to someone else who can. But that's the concern I have, is like, oh, what does it say to outsiders if we can't really comment on it kind of respectfully? Yeah, what we actually do know. But I do think that where it is helpful as a teacher, right, and I think that that transversal, as you said, issues in society today are not neat categories of the different fields. You know, the builder in first year, but that actually the way in which you go from seed to, you know, food disposal touches on all these kind of different kinds of areas that, if you're practicing, you're going to have to think about kind of different areas. And so I do think it has a tremendous amount of pedagogical value, and I think that we should offer courses.

Policy. So, so yeah, it's like, how do you—you can teach it, but it's not ideal, but I don't know. It's a good example of transversal interdisciplinarity. So yeah, because that's kind of—I'm still searching. But I do think that we're, like I said before, in the early stages here, so maybe over time there will be more depth. Oh, and the last thing, just because I think it's relevant to point out, I do think in Canada one of the reasons also why this is a challenge is because I do think we have a very significant linguistic divide, and I think that there are things happening in Quebec that are not known outside of the province and vice versa. And so I do think that federalism, different provincial powers, but also linguistic divides mean that, you know, we are even more limited in terms of having those shared spaces to reflect. So that's another thing. I don't know if I have anything entirely particular to add. I mean, it just, it occurs to me that we're having such an interesting conversation about explicitness that other folks just don't have to have. When the doctrine does the work of saying, This is why you are in this conference, it's easy, property, whatever, come, all my best—cross all the very—they have a list too. But we do get to have these conversations, and I'm just, you know, pulling on the threads of strategy, it just seems to be so interesting how—and it's so very distributed, like none of us can do it for anyone else, but we're all sort of collectively doing it together. Like this balance between enough flexibility so that lots of people can get grants under the umbrella of food, right? But also, like, we have to answer the question, like, what is not food law? Or the question of how to create enough depth for that practitioner to then actually be able to think with food systems. And I think that's a really—it's a lovely challenge that the people in this distributed way are just balancing between kind of flexibility and then some sort of definition. I don't know how to capture that, but it feels like people have done over the last 10, 20 years and are doing a really... I don't know, just communicate something that has this dynamic tension. That's a good question, if you're comfortable. Why do, other than just population, let's say over 20, why do you think if you want to read and make these perceptions of creativity, that in the United States it's started being then it just exploded, whereas in Canada it sort of seems to be gradually rather than exploded? I don't know if it wasn't, I don't know. Does it feel like it's exploding here? Oh, does it feel like... does it go? Yeah. Yeah. But the scale is so different, right? We have like 20 law schools, whereas in the United States has like, I don't know how many law schools, we have hundreds. So there's also more. It's true. Like, the fact that we have professors teaching at most or half of the law schools, I don't know, a third, that seems... Which, in 10 years, that is, I guess that is exploding. Yeah, I mean, I don't know. But I think the scale question is at least part of the answer. Yeah. There's also one big act in the U.S. which we don't have, which founds a history different than ours, I think. Sorry, go ahead. No, no, go ahead. I was going to pick up the point that you were asking, so like, why do we have to do this when others don't? And actually my mind isn't so much the property, it's not just about, it's like the other environmental, marine, energy law, which seem more kind of like comparators to us, you know, I don't know what you call them, like they're not conventional legal subjects so much as they're, you know...

Hey, yeah, I don't know if there's somewhere to stand that Renata can see us better, or is there— The owl should move. Oh, okay, amazing. I can't see you, Angela. Okay, amazing. I can't see you. Oh, there. I'll continue, Angela. Okay, awesome. Oh, my camera's on. No, no, no, you do what you need to do. No, I just wanted to make a couple of points paralleling with animal law here, and I do think that self-doubt is probably just endemic to a young field. And so, Sarah, you mentioned international law. Like, I remember this from the 1990s. This was like, you know, ad nauseam, this international law, law, and it's exhausting. Like, why should you have to spend all this energy, like, justifying yourself and your existence, right? So, I don't know. My view of animal law is we just keep saying it is, and it will be. And that's just kind of, you know, how to—like, just as a practical matter, it's probably good just to carry forward like that. And for us, I think also we're thinking, okay, it's good to have almost like a short elevator pitch that you can, you know what I mean, if you have a tall building, you can get it out. But, you know, what we've been working on with some U.S. colleagues for a course book is just to say, look, it casts a wide net. Animal law is anything that touches and concerns animals, but there's three levels. One is animals are subordinate to humans, and humans are allowed to use animals for whatever they, you know, sort of want to do. So that's instrumental use of animals, and most of the law is that. Then we have the intertwined, animals intertwined with humans, and so that's like anything that's sort of like one healthy, or that is wildlife, or wildlife corridors, things like that. And then you have intrinsic value for animals, where that's what's being recognized. And, you know, obviously there's much less of this, but ideally over time we want to have more. And I do think that that kind of, I don't know, we're just, we're working on it. We're hoping that that's good, that's sort of understandable. I use it for my course to sort of just frame everything for the students, and— I don't know, it's interesting because I would say when I first started doing this as a big course five years ago, the most common question I got was, What is animal law? And at that time, I didn't have this pitch yet, and so I kind of struggled, and I would just say, Oh, it's anything that concerns animals, you know. But now, I'm finding actually nobody asks me that anymore, you know, and they know there's a program, there's a big course, there's fellowships, there's events, there's all, you know, so they're just like, Oh, okay, you know. And I do feel like that just takes probably time. And I do think that the media aspect of it is also very important because, I don't know, since we started in 2025, like, I probably, I think I just asked my research associate to count, we've done 40 media interviews talking about animals in the media. And granted, these are mostly not animals we eat. These are cats and dogs, the whales at Marineland, and the elephants. We're trying to get the elephant bill revived. So people are very open to the animals we don't eat, and of course it's very, very different for animals that we do eat. But, you know, we operate on the premise that eventually you will get also to the animals that we do eat. So anyway, I don't know. I'm just sharing our experience because I do think, you know, you guys have been doing this longer and, you know, the self-doubt, like, I feel like I've been coming to this conference every now and again, like Nadia, when you organized it at U of T, it was the first time I went. I went to the Ottawa one last year. It just feels very developed to me, and you guys are the leaders of it, and I just would just, yeah, be like, No, we are. And I think it's okay, like, privately to be thinking, Oh, you know, let's reflect and be introspective and so on and so forth. But I just don't think it's very fair that young fields have to spend so much energy on this, you know, defending and justifying themselves. I really, you know, yeah. So anyway, those are my two cents. I mean, I feel like, Isabel, by the way, you're saying is like similar maybe what Nadia is saying is like that articulation of those common elements that do tie us together to a degree are like, it’s not so much values that you're describing as, it's kind of features that we feel. I don't know how you describe it. Just to, let me come back what you said about energy law, because I've been teaching climate law, energy law, international environmental law, some areas that international environmental law had a moment of crisis in the beginning because we never had an international environmental organization as we do now. So it was very fragmented in the beginning. But I think a set of common values, shared values, or accepted values helped to settle this debate. But I don't see a lot of question yourself doubt in climate law or energy law. It's just, you know, people take for granted. But one thing that comes to mind, which is even an earlier question is—

Why is food law a young area of law, or about food law? Because if you think about this, since 1945 we have the FAO, right, the Food and Agriculture Organization. We always had agriculture laws, always had many food laws. So it's interesting to me to see that, like, we have a human rights law also, like as a settled area since after World War, we have, right, some health law already. So why is it that food law has been more resisted, or it only became—I do not have the answer. I'm just curious if this question about the exceptionalism of food protection, etc., plays a role there. Because I see, like, food systems and agricultural food systems, agri-food, it seems so clear that it is something that needs to be centered so that we can tackle it, we can address. Like that if we try to just take the health and food, environment and food, very separate, trade and food, it's not going to work. So to me, centering food systems as an area that you can study all the different laws and how they interrelate would be something that is a no-brainer. So it's just, yeah, just food for thought that I find it interesting that we still have this discussion specifically of food law and why so late. I think my understanding is that what's new is the idea of food law policy is something that's bigger than the sum of its parts, because we know that, you know, food and drug... The regulations existed, and people, we've had the laws related to food fraud for millennia. So, like, we know that laws in relation to food are not new, but what's new is the idea of seeing it as a field. And that's why, like, 10 years ago, people who did self-identify as food lawyers previously realized that they had this shared—but it was more than, like, I work on, like, regulatory compliance with, you know, novel foods, and not seeing that, and that that was an important health, right? Someone else was doing labor, and it turns out they were doing labor in relation to agriculture. And so food law and policy, I think maybe even there's a problem with the name, because we've had food laws forever. The point is that we're trying to do something different in food policy that probably needs—in first of all, like, I mean, it's food law and agricultural policy, and then we're missing fish, but someone in French is bioagrimonta, like agroalimentaire, but bioalimentaire, and bio specifically is no use to reference, you know, fish or aquatic. So, like, even food law and policy to me is—I'm always trying to add the, like, agri-food law and policy, because the point—that's also in the U.S., where the field emerged, is because there was agricultural law, and schools teaching agricultural law, and then there were schools teaching the Food and Drugs Act, and then the big thing was, oh, we're going to bring them together. And that's where then kind of food, potentially, you gain in, like, a broader conception, but you also lose in coherence, because just because you do work on novel foods doesn't mean that you have thoughts on farmland succession. And what is the thing that holds them together? to make an agri-food law and policy. Can I just comment? I think that's a really interesting question. So what was it about us that made sense to think about production, distribution, consumption, regulation all together recently, and why not before? Because I don't know. I feel like that's a very interesting genealogical question. Like, why did we do that? Is it like a desire for system? I don't know, what's the—I always think everything's always about, like, capitalism, the [unclear]. But, you know, what kind of resistance was it, or, you know, that—it is a really interesting thing about why these desires to integrate really disparate pieces have captivated so many people to be in community with each other. Yeah, I mean, maybe it's like also, like, when you're thinking about, for example, it's crisis, you know, like that, they get, like, maybe there's that kind of narrative. The other thing I was wondering, as you're talking, like, on the climate comparison, which is so interesting, because in some ways it's a sort of subfield of environmental, I guess, but it's also its own field to a degree, or maybe I don't know how you think about it. But I also presume that, like, when you go—

To a climate conference, you do have a certain consensus already there. And I kind of wonder maybe some questions, like what are you disagreeing about? You know, what are the terms of disagreement that you have at those conferences? Do they look like the terms of disagreement that we would have at this conference, or do they look different because people are coming with, you know, like, you know, they're trying to, to some extent, respond to the climate crisis, and that that's common frame. It's very similar in the sense that people are coming from very different perspectives, and we share some elements of environmental principles, precautionary principles, in the [unclear], but not necessarily implemented. So that's why I think it's interesting for me, because the ones who we start to have a critical mass of international climate laws, national climate laws, stop discussing if it's a field. It is a field. There is enough, like, laws that are interlinked, like in different levels, especially, but also in terms of the interdisciplinary as well, and how much law we have in science. So there is different, right? So yes, it's environment, but there are some specific things about climate, which I think is very similar to food. Like food has its own specificities, right? So it has, like, nutrition and health, and then the trade, which is quite different than other areas. It's different to the energy trade, for example. So there are some specificities, because then there is food sovereignty, which is similar in a way but different than energy sovereignty. So yeah, it's just interesting to me, like, to see how it is. Can it be kind of a debate? Is this still a field? I think, like, to me, so, like, it is a field. Enough laws in different levels, this very, like, interlinked sectoral food systems for me make a lot of sense, and there's no way to do this without having this field of food law and policy, where that's the only place where you're going to try to see. Food systems work globally and to try to respond more holistically, because otherwise it's very piecemeal, looking from a health perspective only, and from a global perspective, from a trade perspective, from a climate perspective, and then trying to make those pieces fit. Yes, I just want to hear, and then we have time for two more. I agree. I think a food wildfire, you're not going to talk about food value chain without resilient food law, right? I'm not saying that's the qualifier, but it's resilient food law. My question for this group is about what is a field in terms of what is the responsibility to ensure to students, especially studying resilient food law, that livelihoods can be made in this field, right? That where is their responsibility to make sure that there is evidence of jobs in this field, employment in this field? My name is Kim Hines. I'm the co-director of the North American Food Systems Network, and we are a sister organization of JSI, the Journal of Agricultural, Food Systems, and Community Development. And I spend every day tracking trends in resilient food systems employment opportunities. One of the things we do is we analyze those job posts, right? And I will tell you, because I have my eyeballs on these opportunities, I'm talking to people looking for work every day, I will tell you that I know a lot of people. The work in policy, I've seen lots of jobs in this field, but very few are looking for that law degree. And so I do feel like there is a disconnect there in terms of what the roles of coalition building, advocacy, all the things, you know, that required, all the skill sets required for good resilient food policy work. I think there's disconnect in what role the legal professional plays there, which is kind of strange when you think about it, but at the same time not, because so much of our work, maybe all of our work, stems from the cornerstone of activism rather than any legal, any profession for that matter. Thanks for the great question. I think...

The answer, I think I see one for Sydney, I can't tell if that's Glenford, but I think it was Glenford, but who has a whole career as a lawyer. I think the question you're asking is an interesting one because it's a challenge that we face in law schools all the time, which is where are the public interest jobs for people who want to challenge food systems or challenge food systems or work for agri-dogs or use law as a tool for social justice or social change? Those jobs are always hard to find, no matter what field you want to work in. But I don't think there's a lack of jobs in what people call food law. It might be hard to locate where you can do them, and it might be hard to build a full practice in food law. But certainly in helping companies comply with food safety laws, in managing trade exchanges, in negotiating instruments for Canada with the government, and in working in rural areas to help farmers do concession or meet various land regulations, there's certainly jobs. The challenge is to find the ones for the people who want to change the system or do the social justice work. I think that's always harder in any area of law. So maybe that's how I would answer that. But I do think also there are very few places that build themselves as food law firms. There are some firms that have practice areas. I, Gwenford's firm was unique in that way. But I think that the challenge is one more broad to the practice of law than just to the practice of food law. But yeah, just to agree with that, I think it's also this conversation that we have in all areas of law, which is the law and policy, right? It's like, to what extent are we training practitioners and we normally do them, and to what extent are we training people to be engaged in policy? And if those are, you know, commensurate with different skill sets, and we're some struggle with how to do that. So maybe there's one more question over here, then we'll— Yeah, I just wondered if any of you spent time kind of thinking through the question by turning the question on its head. Like, why do we think of other areas of law? Why do we not challenge that they're fields of law, right? Like, why do we think of property contracts or constitutional as established fields of law? You know, I would say that they're established and normalized from prior colonization to today, right? So kind of thinking through the question in that space-time dimension. And so I'd say that any new field of law is going to be a challenge to that system to some extent or to the status quo. So, you know, I think quite obviously we need these more horizontal fields of law, as I talked in my environmental law students option about, environmental law being this horizontal area that touches on all these other areas, because I think it can kind of unsettle that there's something natural or inevitable about a particular field of law and its legitimacy. So I guess just the final thing that I wanted to say is, I think, you know, we can just be unapologetic about the existence of fields of food loss, because I think it will provide a space through any rupture that occurs, unlike these more siloed areas of loss that won't. So I'm just wondering if any of you have spent... There has been a lot of discussion in our loss, that we are going to...

Make notes like this from your own meetings

Record a meeting — Roomtone writes the summary, the decisions and the action items.

Get Roomtone free →